The skin around your eyes is thinner and more absorbent than anywhere else on your face, which makes ingredient quality of the makeup you use especially important. Many conventional eye products contain talc, phthalates, coal tar dyes, and synthetic fragrance that can irritate eyes and disrupt hormones over time. These non-toxic picks rely on plant pigments, nourishing oils, and mineral-based ingredients to deliver performance without compromising your health.
Why Choose Non-Toxic Eye Makeup?
For a deeper dive into how we choose non-toxic eye makeup, read more on our Substack. Some of our favorite brands include Toups & Co, 100% Pure, and Ogee. Shop our Amazon Storefront for even more picks.
This mascara uses organic jojoba oil and oat-derived proteins to condition and support lash health, while mineral pigments add volume and definition. It is ideal for bold lashes without irritation or the heaviness that can come from conventional mascara. Available in black.
This colored brow gel uses green tea fiber, seaweed powder, provitamin B5, and vitamin E to naturally add shape, fullness and hold without synthetic fragrance, alcohol, and harsh preservatives. We love it for its soft, flexible brow definition that lasts all day.
These pressed shadows are colored with fruit pigments and formulated with cocoa butter and vitamin E for smooth application. Available in more than 10 nude and pink individual shades in both matte and shimmer, we love them for their buildable color that feels comfortable all day.
This all natural eyeliner uses castor oil, organic coconut oil, and carnauba wax for smooth, tug-free application while supporting eyelash health. It works well for daily definition without irritating sensitive eyes. Available in black and brown shades.
A waterless botanical serum made with adaptogenic ingredients like gotu kola, burdock root, and horsetail to support lash and brow density, with noticeable results as soon as a few weeks. It avoids synthetic fragrance and harsh preservatives, making it a gentle option for consistent growth support.
This serum uses 100% organic castor oil to condition lashes and brows with nourishing fatty acids and without added fragrance, preservatives, or fillers. We recommend it for nightly use to support stronger-looking lashes naturally.
This ergonomic stainless steel curler uses thick, rounded silicone pads instead of the rubber pads found on most conventional curlers, which can stick to lashes and cause breakage over time. It is free from latex and the irritating rubber compounds that make cheaper curlers problematic for sensitive eyes, and the silicone pads are replaceable and easy to clean with a simple alcohol wipe between uses. We like it as a durable, non-toxic lash tool built to last and gentle enough for daily use.
This lash-lengthening and volumizing formula features nourishing oils and mineral pigments for definition without clumping or irritation. We like it for clean, natural-looking lashes that do not flake or sting. Available in black and dark brown.
This cream luminizer uses organic coconut oil and mineral pigments to add a soft glow to eyes and cheekbones. It avoids silicones and artificial colors to create a subtle, buildable, natural makeup look. It works well for highlighting inner corners or lids without irritation and is available in Rose Gold and Champagne shades.
This palette uses mineral pigments and plant extracts to deliver 3 rich eyeshadow colors without irritation. It leaves out synthetic dyes, talc, and fragrance, with shades that apply smoothly and blend easily. It is a versatile option for everyday looks and sensitive eyes. Available in Original, with matte bark, matte flesh, and iced mocha pigments, and Date Night, with a berry hued palette.
This volumizing, water-resistant mascara uses maracuja oil, lash conditioning vitamins like vitamin E and provitamin B5, and green tea, cocoa, and coffee pigments to color lashes while adding definition. It leaves out carbon black, synthetic fragrance, and harsh solvents, making it a great everyday mascara for sensitive eyes. Available in black, brown, and blue shades.
This brow pencil uses organic avocado butter and mineral pigments to define, fill in, and condition brows without synthetic fragrance, talc, and petroleum-based fillers. Available in six neutral shades from platinum blonde to black, it is ideal for natural-looking brow shaping with added nourishment.
